Tina Gajda Tina Gajda

Don't Let Great Candidates Get Away!

A résumé is more than a collection of keywords, and a candidate is more than a compatibility score.

A résumé tells a story. Are you taking the time to read it?

We've identified the position, developed an accurate job description, and advertised the opportunity to attract qualified candidates. Now the applications are coming in. What happens next?

For many organizations, technology has become the first gatekeeper. Applicant tracking systems and increasingly sophisticated AI tools can scan résumés, identify keywords, and rank applicants against predetermined qualifications.

I understand the appeal. When hundreds of applications arrive, automation can save time. But here's where I have a problem: A résumé is more than a collection of keywords, and a candidate is more than a compatibility score.

Consider this:

An applicant in your pool of resumes has spent six years with a small company, progressing from an administrative assistant to an office coordinator and eventually to operations manager. Their résumé might not contain every industry-specific keyword in your job posting. Their employer might be a company you've never heard of. Their job titles might not reflect the full scope of their responsibilities.

But look closer.

That individual has demonstrated professional growth, earned increasing responsibility, and potentially developed a broad range of transferable skills. That is someone I want to talk to.

Throughout my HR career, I've believed that evaluating applicants requires more than matching words on a page. It requires understanding the position, recognizing potential, and applying consistent, job-related standards. I use a structured evaluation process to assess candidates against the established requirements of a role. Those who meet the qualifications move forward to an initial HR screening.

And yes, that means taking the time to actually review their résumés.

The First Conversation Matters

Advancing candidates receive an initial 30-minute virtual conversation. This isn't meant to replace the hiring manager's interview. It's an opportunity to confirm qualifications, explore communication and teamwork skills relevant to the position, discuss compensation and benefits, and answer questions about the organization.

It's also an opportunity for the candidate to decide whether the employer and position align with their own goals.

When candidates move forward, I want hiring managers to form their own impressions. I provide their résumés and supporting application materials rather than my personal ratings.

Don't Let the Process Become the Problem

Another concern I have with today's hiring practices is that organizations can spend so much time screening candidates that they lose the very people they hoped to attract. Qualified applicants are often exploring multiple opportunities. They shouldn't have to wait weeks simply to learn whether someone reviewed their application.

Review applications promptly. Communicate respectfully. Move qualified candidates forward without unnecessary delays.

And when someone doesn't meet the requirements, it’s OK. Let them know now rather than leaving them wondering for weeks or months … and ghosting candidates altogether is simply bad practice.

Technology Should Support the Process, Not Replace Human Judgment

I'm not opposed to using technology to organize applications or identify obvious mismatches. However, I strongly believe that decisions about people's professional opportunities deserve thoughtful human consideration.

An automated system may help you manage the volume, but an experienced human reviewer can recognize the potential that a checklist alone might miss. And sometimes, that overlooked candidate becomes your next exceptional employee.

At Willow Tree Strategies & Solutions, I help organizations develop thoughtful, structured talent acquisition practices that balance efficiency with the human judgment great hiring requires. Because finding the right person isn't simply about filling an opening.

It's about recognizing talent.

Next in the series: The Offer Is More Than a Phone Call.

Read More